League Voting

Status    Subject Created By Replies Views Last Post
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling Tentative Expansion for 1993 season?
Commish 14 245 by PhilliesGM
Jan 21, 2020 9:26:40 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling Trading recently signed players
Commish 7 200 by PadresGM
Nov 27, 2019 19:59:38 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling Future Sim Schedule?
Cory 6 185 by Commish
May 12, 2019 8:03:26 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling League Structure Vote
Commish 8 241 by MarinersGM
Mar 3, 2019 14:37:11 GMT -5
newBookmarkLockedFalling League Structure for 1988 and beyond
Commish 22 396 by MarinersGM
Feb 27, 2019 0:06:05 GMT -5
newBookmarkLockedFalling ROLL CALL
MetsGM 22 375 by RangersGM
Jan 31, 2019 4:56:49 GMT -5
newBookmarkLockedFalling Arbitration Formula Proposal
CardinalsGM 5 143 by AsGM
Jan 13, 2019 23:48:28 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling Career-ending injuries
Commish 3 188 by Commish
Oct 27, 2018 13:30:24 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling Arbitration/Compensation system
Commish 12 306 by CardinalsGM
Oct 14, 2018 22:41:04 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling League structure
Commish 14 351 by MarinersGM
Sept 4, 2018 20:38:27 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling Opening Sim
Commish 4 232 by Commish
Jul 26, 2018 21:07:57 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling Contraction draft contracts
Commish 7 180 by Commish
Jul 18, 2018 21:15:35 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling No-Trade Clauses
Commish 7 186 by CardinalsGM
Jul 17, 2018 22:13:20 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling Arizona Fall League
Commish 2 127 by Commish
Jul 13, 2018 19:43:44 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling Career Stats
Commish 2 121 by Commish
Jul 13, 2018 19:43:15 GMT -5
newPollBookmarkLockedFalling Designated hitter
Commish 0 131 by Commish
Jul 10, 2018 6:57:55 GMT -5


Thread Announcement Sticky Locked new New Poll Bookmark

Board Information & Statistics

Board Description
League Voting
Commish will post various league items for discussion and voting.
Board Statistics
Threads and Posts
Total Threads:16
Total Posts:151
On This Board
You can create threads.
You can reply to threads.
You can create polls.
Members Online
Users Viewing
0 Staff, 0 Members, 1 Guest.


CubsGM: If a player has 8 contact or seven contact with 9-10 power, you have a starting MLB player. If the average were 5s, then a 10 would completely dominate to such a point that he would be hitting .400 plus and/o 80+ HRs. Apr 2, 2020 15:04:30 GMT -5
PadresGM: like i said before...these players aren't being created this way, but rather the game itself is boosting them through player development changes Apr 3, 2020 12:40:13 GMT -5
CubsGM: Agreed Apr 3, 2020 14:27:21 GMT -5
CardinalsGM: The game engine determines overall stats based on a league total... and distributes stats throughout the players by a combination of past stats and ratings. Apr 4, 2020 11:27:30 GMT -5
CardinalsGM: It doesn't just say -- eh, this guy is a 5 so he sucks. If the average of the league were 5's, then those players would be roughly producing a league average stat. Apr 4, 2020 11:29:14 GMT -5
CardinalsGM: And the 10's would be people far more likely to produce at a larger deviation from the average. Apr 4, 2020 11:29:42 GMT -5
CardinalsGM: I just agreed with commish that the issue is likely more a product of having fewer teams than anything. More teams=a more widely distributed talent level and 50 more players in the MLB level. Apr 4, 2020 11:32:56 GMT -5
CardinalsGM: You shouldn't have to have a 7 contact mixed with 10 power to be MLB. 5 and 7 should get you there, just fine, especially when our A-level and late draft picks are 2-3's. 10's should be exceedingly rare, and YES, they would be more likely to dominate. Apr 4, 2020 11:38:42 GMT -5
MarinersGM: In your proposed mechanic, and to Cubs point, the 10s that the game engine would produce would result in absurd outcomes like 80+ homer seasons, over .400 averages, etc. I’ve been in leagues like that and it’s no fun because it’s not realistic. Apr 4, 2020 11:57:04 GMT -5
MarinersGM: one player can make far too much of a difference and upset the balance of the league. I think the settings in this league are much better than your proposal and leave just a few outliers like Bonds and Sheffield but their numbers still aren’t unrealistic Apr 4, 2020 11:58:00 GMT -5
MarinersGM: and also we all agree that a few more teams would spread the talent out a bit and should fix part of your concern. Apr 4, 2020 11:58:50 GMT -5
CubsGM: There are settings. I don't know what they are for this league. I think this league is very close to perfect as it is right now. Apr 4, 2020 12:02:07 GMT -5
CubsGM: I am not a fan of expansion drafts, nor of expanding without stronger activity with current GMs. Apr 4, 2020 12:02:46 GMT -5
CardinalsGM: You know what else is unrealistic? When teams trade 25 players for one, because everybody agrees that anything beyond the 2nd round draft pick is nearly worthless. That's directly a result of MLB ratings being out of reach for most players drafted. Apr 5, 2020 11:51:58 GMT -5
CardinalsGM: The only way of dealing with that is making sure we don't have the "average" MLB player's ratings be too high relative to later draft picks. Apr 5, 2020 11:53:35 GMT -5
CardinalsGM: Again, I'm in agreement with the commish that most of this is due to a condensed talent pool into only 18 teams. Apr 5, 2020 11:54:25 GMT -5
CubsGM: I disagree. Trades should be regulated by the Commish/league rules. Keeping the talent so low that MLB players are average 5s is not going to affect the individual creativity of two GMs who are finding a way to trade. Most of the leagues I’ve been in Apr 5, 2020 13:07:30 GMT -5
CubsGM: have had trade councils. Apr 5, 2020 13:07:37 GMT -5
CubsGM: Our first issue is a lack of consistent activity by our GMs. Apr 5, 2020 13:08:35 GMT -5
MarinersGM: is there a sim today? Apr 5, 2020 13:50:56 GMT -5